Reply
Apr 04 2014
By: AKyemeni Naughty Paw 9851 posts
Online

[FEEDBACK] The Mesh Map Thread

[ Edited ]
59 replies 972 views Edited May 2, 2014

Hello Uncharted 3 Community!

 

As you all are probably aware and have witnessed, Naughty Dog continues to support Uncharted 3 multiplayer through patches and live updates. The Uncharted 3 community's feedback is of utmost importance to Naughty Dog. This is one of those instances in which feedback is important to them. 

 

Naughty Dog wants your feedback on the various Mesh Maps that have been released since their introduction to the Lab. This will help them choose which Mesh Maps they should put into rotation in matchmaking. 

 

In this thread, please choose 6 out of the 13 Mesh Maps (Including Dodgeball) in which you would like to see in the Lab matchmaking playlist and briefly describe why you would like to see these maps in the playlist. 

 

If you need help in deciding which Mesh Map is which or if you need a reminder on how the Mesh Maps look like, please click on the following thread:

 

THE BLOCK MESH MAP THREAD (COURTESY OF canadian94eh)

 

A tally of the chosen maps will be kept in the Original Post and will be updated regularly.

 

 

Mesh Map 1: 24

 

Mesh Map 2:  17

 

Mesh Map 3: 20

 

Mesh Map 4: 18 

 

Mesh Map 5:  14

 

Mesh Map 6: 4

 

Mesh Map 7: 2

 

Mesh Map 8: 7

 

Mesh Map 9: 21

 

Mesh Map 10: 10

 

Mesh Map 11: 23

 

Mesh Map 12:  7

 

Mesh Map Dodgeball: 5

 

 

FINALsignatureAK.png

Message 1 of 60 (972 Views)
Fender Bender
Registered: 12/27/2012
Online
2849 posts
 

Re: The Mesh Map Feedback Thread

[ Edited ]
Apr 4, 2014

Here goes I choose.

Mesh Map #1 - Balanced map, caters to all playstyles and has a lot of verticality.

Mesh Map #3 - As it's a pretty versatile map with a slight edge for long range weapons but overall it can be a fun map & feel like it hasn't gotten enough time to shine in the Lab.

Mesh Map #4 - Basically my favorite & in my opinion the best Mesh Map to be released from the lot.

Mesh Map #5 - One of the best close quarter maps to ever grace the uncharted multiplayer.

Mesh Map #9 - Very balanced & Fun map combines two of the best UC2 maps into one which are Fort & Sanctuary can't go wrong with that.

Mesh Map #11 - This map is simply amazing & allows every form of playstyle to shine & it's the best custom games map ever ^^
 

Message 2 of 60 (954 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Treasure Hunter
Registered: 12/29/2009
Offline
4896 posts
 

Re: The Mesh Map Feedback Thread

[ Edited ]
Apr 5, 2014

Mesh Map 9 - The most balanced map out of all the maps.

Mesh Map 12 - Edit: Boycotting no 1 with no 12.

Mesh Map 2 - I don't object to it as much as everyone else.

Mesh Map 3 - McDonalds playhouse tunnel
Mesh Map 11 - Very large map and accomodates all playstyles

Mesh Map 10 - Thought it was balanced too but confusing.

 

Those would be my picks.

 

Edit: Changed my mind, I don't want number 1 anymore.

Message 3 of 60 (946 Views)
First Son
Registered: 06/20/2012
Offline
20 posts
 

Re: The Mesh Map Feedback Thread

[ Edited ]
Apr 4, 2014

Mesh Map 1 – high and low it’s a fun map

Mesh Map 2 – I has symmetry

Mesh Map 3 – Who doesn’t like the half pipe!

Mesh Map 4 – Good map, wasn’t in rotation long enough
Mesh Map 9 – One of my favorites, nice map!

Mesh Map 12 – I has Gazeibo

 

 

Make it happen Smiley Happy

Message 4 of 60 (934 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
PlayStation MVP
Registered: 02/03/2009
Offline
684 posts
 

Re: The Mesh Map Feedback Thread

Apr 4, 2014

My votes:
#9
#11
#3
#2
#12
#10

Thanks for the update on this too and the continued support. Been missing some good 'ole Meshie fun Smiley Very Happy

Twitter: @HeaneyWeeny
http://www.youtube.com/user/ThePattyCakeChamp
Message 5 of 60 (930 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Lombax Warrior
Registered: 06/14/2013
Offline
158 posts
 

Re: The Mesh Map Feedback Thread

Apr 4, 2014

mine are

BMM 4 which is the best as its balanced

BMM 1 is awesome as it was the first BMM

BMM 2 is also good

BMM 5 nice for team fight with balanced power weapon

BMM 9 Is the 2nd best map after 4 which is really good and very well balanced

and the last BMM 11 which is awesome huge map

Message 6 of 60 (915 Views)
Last Guardian
Registered: 11/24/2011
Offline
11242 posts
 

Re: The Mesh Map Feedback Thread

Apr 4, 2014

#1

#2

#4

#9

#10

#11

...

Message 7 of 60 (900 Views)
Splicer
Registered: 04/22/2013
Offline
73 posts
 

Re: The Mesh Map Feedback Thread

Apr 4, 2014

Block Mesh #2 - I like it more than the other maps I didn't choose

Block Mesh #3 - It's personally my favorite block mesh map out of em all.

Block Mesh #4 - Very good & balanced map.

Block Mesh # 9 - Another balanced map which I also think is good.

Block Mesh #10 - Haven't seen or played on this map much since it was first taken out of rotation. 

Block Mesh #12 - I've rarely played this map since it first debuted. 

Message 8 of 60 (885 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Fender Bender
Registered: 12/02/2011
Offline
2220 posts
 

Re: The Mesh Map Feedback Thread

[ Edited ]
Apr 4, 2014

Picking six maps is harder than I thought it would be, don't suppose I can vote for #14? First four are easy though.

Block Mesh Map #11 - Great map, safe spawns, and friendly for all players. Camping could be a problem, but only if you didn't know all the routes, as there were at least four ways to access every area. -11/10

Block Mesh Map #4 - On this map, it was the first time I saw all six loadout long guns in one match, that has to mean something good. The layout was incredibly fun too, you could climb everything. - 10/10

Block Mesh Map #5 - Layout was slightly strange, but not bad, just different. Friendly map for close range, but it didn't force it on you. This is what I want from close quarter maps, something #2, #12 and even Desert Village couldn't deliver. - 8/10

Block Mesh Map #3 - Bad spawns, but the layout was epic! I loved shooting snipers with the Tau on the zipline, then taking a quick escape through the yellow tunnel. - 5/10 on a competitive scale, but 10/10 on a fun scale.

Block Mesh Map #1 - Had fun on it the first time it appeared, but the last time I only saw M9's and KAL's everywhere, I can only hope it's improved since 1.18. - ?/10

Block Mesh Map #9 - Couldn't decide between #9 and #10, wasn't a huge fan of either of these maps, they weren't bad, just... Basic... Went with #9 since it seems more popular (I remember a small amount of hate towards #10). - Meh/10

Pepsi
Message 9 of 60 (873 Views)
Treasure Hunter
Registered: 05/13/2010
Offline
3877 posts
 

Re: The Mesh Map Feedback Thread

Apr 5, 2014
1
11
3
9
5
4

Thank you ND Smiley Happy


Message 10 of 60 (837 Views)