Reply
Sackboy
Registered: 11/20/2005
Offline
593 posts
 

Re: KHII GS REVIEW (CAPS)

Mar 29, 2006


Aeris_Jayle wrote:


Dannyboy2k4 wrote:


fs_metal wrote:


Aeris_Jayle wrote:


fs_metal wrote:


JDplasma11 wrote:


fs_metal wrote:


JDplasma11 wrote:
Wow. This is the final straw- I'm not going to GS anymore. They obviously don't play the games they review. SE got an 8.7, this got an 8.7, Subsistence got a mere 9... This is bull


Oblivion got a 9.6, so they obviously know what they are talking about, atleast to some degree


Well, then, put 2 and 2 together- so far, every major PS2 release that came out recently was given lower scores by GS than everyone else. Oblivion and GRAW got phenominal scores. Someone's slipping GS a bit of $ under the table.



I do not see what is to be so pissed off about Subsistence gettng a 9.0. I mean, it is a remake. Remakes NEVER EVER score that high in anything. That is a fantastic score for a remake


I'm not complaining about a 9 either.... and neither am I complaining about the 8.7 for KH2....  Those are both fantastic scores in my book!  KH2 is an awesome game, and so is Subsistence, but neither are truly perfect, no game is....

I could make an arguement aboud Doom, but I don't wanna Smiley Tongue


Or one of the Zelda games (OoT perhaps?).


I hated the 3D Zelda games, they're not even close to the greatness that was A Link to the Past....  3D Zelda and Mario games are seriously overrated....


what? i loved OoT! so fun and it had a great replay value... but were all entitled to our opinions
to tell you the truth tho, your reading my sig
_______________________________________________________
"And I Forget Just Why I Taste... Oh Ya I Guess It Makes Me Smile"

IM A COUPON!

Message 21 of 37 (1 View)
Reply
0 Likes
I Only Post Everything
Registered: 08/20/2004
Offline
1041 posts
 

Re: KHII GS REVIEW (CAPS)

Mar 29, 2006


Aeris_Jayle wrote:


Dannyboy2k4 wrote:


fs_metal wrote:


Aeris_Jayle wrote:


fs_metal wrote:


JDplasma11 wrote:


fs_metal wrote:


JDplasma11 wrote:
Wow. This is the final straw- I'm not going to GS anymore. They obviously don't play the games they review. SE got an 8.7, this got an 8.7, Subsistence got a mere 9... This is bull


Oblivion got a 9.6, so they obviously know what they are talking about, atleast to some degree


Well, then, put 2 and 2 together- so far, every major PS2 release that came out recently was given lower scores by GS than everyone else. Oblivion and GRAW got phenominal scores. Someone's slipping GS a bit of $ under the table.



I do not see what is to be so pissed off about Subsistence gettng a 9.0. I mean, it is a remake. Remakes NEVER EVER score that high in anything. That is a fantastic score for a remake


I'm not complaining about a 9 either.... and neither am I complaining about the 8.7 for KH2....  Those are both fantastic scores in my book!  KH2 is an awesome game, and so is Subsistence, but neither are truly perfect, no game is....

I could make an arguement aboud Doom, but I don't wanna Smiley Tongue


Or one of the Zelda games (OoT perhaps?).


I hated the 3D Zelda games, they're not even close to the greatness that was A Link to the Past....  3D Zelda and Mario games are seriously overrated....

Mario 64 was kinda bad IMO......but the 3D Zelda games were great. At its very core, Kingdom Hearts copied alot of the 3D Zelda's gameplay.
Message 22 of 37 (1 View)
Reply
0 Likes
Treasure Hunter
Registered: 11/10/2005
Offline
7716 posts
 

Re: KHII GS REVIEW (CAPS)

Mar 29, 2006
T think as far as transfering from 2d games to 3d games goes, Sonic did the best job. Sonic Adventure 1 and 2 are 2 og the best games ever made IMO. I love them.

Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting
Joined GAP: 6-2-06
Message 23 of 37 (1 View)
Reply
0 Likes
Treasure Hunter
Registered: 10/02/2004
Offline
7003 posts
 

Re: KHII GS REVIEW (CAPS)

Mar 29, 2006
Odd it only got one 8 and the rest were 9's then it got an 8.7
 
Message 24 of 37 (1 View)
Reply
0 Likes
Treasure Hunter
Registered: 08/13/2005
Offline
5038 posts
 

Re: KHII GS REVIEW (CAPS)

Mar 29, 2006


fs_metal wrote:
T think as far as transfering from 2d games to 3d games goes, Sonic did the best job. Sonic Adventure 1 and 2 are 2 og the best games ever made IMO. I love them.



I agree with you completely! SA 2 is a great game, not only the mechanics and fast-passed racing action, but even the music is awesome! I love the theme of the first and second game so much!
Message 25 of 37 (1 View)
Reply
0 Likes
Treasure Hunter
Registered: 11/10/2005
Offline
7716 posts
 

Re: KHII GS REVIEW (CAPS)

Mar 29, 2006


Ark_v2 wrote:


fs_metal wrote:
T think as far as transfering from 2d games to 3d games goes, Sonic did the best job. Sonic Adventure 1 and 2 are 2 og the best games ever made IMO. I love them.



I agree with you completely! SA 2 is a great game, not only the mechanics and fast-passed racing action, but even the music is awesome! I love the theme of the first and second game so much!

The inclusion of Knuckles ruled as well. I love Knuckles man. He is bad ass

Hell, I gotta be honest. I always prefered Soinic to Mario. Better and more in depth story (it doesn't really matter on side scrollers but whatever). Killer level design. Mario never did anything as cool as the casino levels. That RULED. The music is alot of fun on Sonic as well. Some cool characters. Sonic and Knuckles both effin rule

Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting
Joined GAP: 6-2-06
Message 26 of 37 (1 View)
Reply
0 Likes
Uncharted Territory
Registered: 04/08/2003
Offline
1624 posts
 

Re: KHII GS REVIEW (CAPS)

Mar 29, 2006
Heh I failed to see how it got a better score than Suikoden V, as a RPG.
 
So the following matter more to RPGamers out there:

From KHII: The Good:Many improvements over the previous game; fixed camera angle and new gameplay dynamics; tons of guest appearances and cameos; wonderfully rich familiar environments; excellent voice acting and music.

Compare to this?

Suikoden V: The Good:Fantastic array of characters to fight, befriend, and recruit; classic battle format works well; character and battle customization additions add depth.
Also I should mention the storyline in Suikoden V is being widely praised for its excellency (which I shall not comment at the moment since I'm not far into the game), whereas KH II generally recieves mediocre ratings for plot. Which further leaves me questioning the credibility of these reviews.

Message Edited by Xin on 03-28-200611:35 PM

Message 27 of 37 (1 View)
Reply
0 Likes
Hekseville Citizen
Registered: 03/15/2004
Offline
432 posts
 

Re: KHII GS REVIEW (CAPS)

Mar 29, 2006


Beastieboy693 wrote:
it got a 40/40 in Famitsu... I think this game deserves a 10/10, but maybe cause im a die hard kh fan


WRONG...


Kingdom Hearts II (PS2, Square Enix) - 10 / 9 / 10 / 10 - (39/40)

 

FFXII got the perfect 40.

Currently Playing: Uncharted, Call of Duty 4, Super Mario Galaxy
Message 28 of 37 (1 View)
Reply
0 Likes
Uncharted Territory
Registered: 03/12/2005
Offline
1561 posts
 

Re: KHII GS REVIEW (CAPS)

Mar 29, 2006
the gamespot editors and ppl who played the game were more into it than ign i guess but yah this game will be mines tommorrow since most of the stores gets it tommorrow though many of the other stores has it today heh..
Currently Playing
=)
MGR (last boss) quene : SC saga!!
Message 29 of 37 (1 View)
Reply
0 Likes
Lombax Warrior
Registered: 03/26/2006
Offline
231 posts
 

Re: KHII GS REVIEW (CAPS)

Mar 29, 2006


JDplasma11 wrote:


fs_metal wrote:


JDplasma11 wrote:
Wow. This is the final straw- I'm not going to GS anymore. They obviously don't play the games they review. SE got an 8.7, this got an 8.7, Subsistence got a mere 9... This is bull


Oblivion got a 9.6, so they obviously know what they are talking about, atleast to some degree


Well, then, put 2 and 2 together- so far, every major PS2 release that came out recently was given lower scores by GS than everyone else. Oblivion and GRAW got phenominal scores. Someone's slipping GS a bit of $ under the table.




yeah apparently they have something against square enix.............................
Message 30 of 37 (1 View)
Reply
0 Likes