I like Cutteridge because it is the 1st place with this atmosphere. Is it scary "No", it is perfect for Halloween and the club version is awesome. The minigame's ultimate reward was not what I expected, sporting squid parts in the lighthouse, sky, well, book, kitchen etc. Hate the squid parts everywhere!!
The squids were totally overdone and made no sense or relevance to the Demonic part. The minigames I enjoyed, a bit frustrating at times but fun. My favorite reward is the antique doll, which you can put in any space creating a haunted atmosphere with ghost child apparitions. Overall if the ratings were very satisfied, satisfied and somewhat satisfied, I would have to vote satisfied for Cutteridge and somewhat satisfied for the ghost stories.
The squids were totally overdone and made no sense or relevance to the Demonic part.
Both beg to differ.
Edit: Check out this blog for many artistic renditions of H. P. Lovecraft's many twisted creature and diety from descriptions of his novels. (NSFW or sanity warning)