Went every day and played and only got three things total, and I wasn't around to play the previous 2011(?) game that gave the same rewards.
If you make sure that one of your "ingredients" is the Mystery Bag (the little brown sac with a yellow ? on it), does that produce a different reward other than the Gothic Chair?
I found the Mystery ? bag in the Hub 3 days before Halloween... creating that particular brew didn't produce anything new for me at that time. I don't know if using that item as an ingredient post-Halloween might do anything. The original Cauldron required you to use specific ingredients to get specific rewards.
Wonder if the Hub Caudron is actually "broken" because we haven't been using the right ingredients it's looking for??
I did not get the chair until Nov. 1st. I also still have not got the table yet either. They really need to do something about rewards in the Hub or start using a different public space. This happens all the time for me in the Hub.
I think it happens to a lot of people at that Hub. You'd think the people at Sony Home would have fixed this by now.
Also, Edisen, as far as I can tell it doesn't matter what ingredients you put into the cauldron, it works or it don't work, depending on whether you have the reward for that day already and the mood the Hub is in.