So it's the chair? Good, I'm not missing out on anything too big. I think I blocked myself out of getting this reward because I went into Home around 12:12 AM thinking it would be there since it was technically Halloween and did the game and got nothing...I think I might've went in too soon. Unless the chair is still popping up at 12:12 AM tonight and hasn't left, which would be nice.
EDIT: Aaaalrighty, never mind, I spoke too soon. I just checked my rewards and it says I've got the chair. Interesting. Well, at least I can say the chair is working, I guess.