Reply
Ghost of Sparta
Registered: 04/05/2003
Offline
13294 posts
 

Re: An Objective Comparison between Xbox One and PS4

Oct 26, 2013

JohnKarnes wrote:

Black0Panther wrote:

PlayBox_One4 wrote:
CoD will run 1080p 60fps on both.

BF4 runs 900p 60fps on both.

Forza runs 1080p 60fps on One.

Killzone runs 1080p 30fps on PS4.

Ryse runs 900p 30fps on One.

Driveclub is struggling to reach 60fps, so was delayed.

Watch Dogs WILL run 1080p 30fps on both.

Pebble 2 will run 1080p 60fps on One (don't know why Smiley Tongue)

It's not a matter of power.

It's not a matter of power.

Far as a post early Killzone will have and unlocked frame rate and expect 60fps just about all of the time. Also if MS Xbone one is more powerful. Why did they overclock it by 10% to  try to compete with the PS4 CPU.

 

http://www.techradar.com/us/news/gaming/consoles/microsoft-overclocking-xbox-one-to-crank-up-its-gra...

 

http://www.techhive.com/article/2048104/xbox-one-hits-the-streets-november-22-overclocked-out-of-the...

 

http://www.extremetech.com/gaming/165630-xbox-one-cpu-speed-boosted-by-10-in-vain-attempt-to-keep-up...

 

There are reports of Xbone one overheating on Devs as well.

 

http://kotaku.com/so-the-xbox-one-still-has-overheating-issues-like-you-1243235074

 

 


They need to turn the over clock back down LOL to reduce the heat !!

Agreed, They overcloced ot try to compete with the PS4 specs.

Message 61 of 66 (208 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Lombax Warrior
Registered: 09/07/2013
Offline
134 posts
 

Re: An Objective Comparison between Xbox One and PS4

[ Edited ]
Oct 26, 2013

PlayBox_One4 wrote:
The clock speed of the PS4 is 800MGHZ. The Xbox One's runs at 853MGHZ.

PS4 CPU  base clock speed is 1.6 Ghz on a 2.75 Ghz capable chip

 

And the memory frequency is 5500MHz

Representing EliteGamingAlliance.

Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCZ-90BMQeBlTbrJJlVLeNLw

Twitch: https://www.twitch.tv/elitegamingalliance/profile
Message 62 of 66 (206 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
I Only Post Everything
Registered: 05/08/2005
Offline
1004 posts
 

Re: An Objective Comparison between Xbox One and PS4

Oct 26, 2013

There's a big difference in GDDR5 and DDR3 in terms of what you're using them for.
GDDR5 has a higher bandwidth but also higher latency. This is good for anything graphics related since they usually need higher bandwidth. Seeing as how the PS4 is pretty much everything graphics related, this is the best choice.

DDR3 has lower latency but also lower bandwidth. This is mainly for when you need to push small amounts of data around which is best for a CPU since it needs to be able to read and write many types of data quickly to the RAM. The Xbox One may possibly have slightly better A.I. in this case. Don't take my word on it though; it's just my opinion.

 

-There's a reason why all the newer computer graphics cards use GDDR5.

 

Here's a link

Message 63 of 66 (171 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
MVP Support
Registered: 08/28/2008
Offline
11146 posts
 

Re: An Objective Comparison between Xbox One and PS4

Oct 26, 2013

Xenomorph235 wrote:

PS4 CPU  base clock speed is 1.6 Ghz on a 2.75 Ghz capable chip

 

And the memory frequency is 5500MHz


This is what I keep coming up with...  not sure where the OP is getting 800MHz.

 

In fact, see that more likely, the PS4 will run safely as high (heat wise) as 2.0-2.2GHz.

Message 64 of 66 (165 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
First Son
Registered: 10/27/2013
Offline
1 posts
 

Re: An Objective Comparison between Xbox One and PS4

Oct 27, 2013

googling for something else i came across this thread by accident, never posted before but the Original post was so infuriating i signed in.

 

I haven't read the whole thread, Just the Original Post.  PlayBox_One4 You are an obvious troll.

 

I must say your post is filled with lie after lie. But the most important lie is the one about the GPU.

 

The PS4 GPU is akin to the AMD7850

 

The Xbox One GPU is the same as an AMD 7770

 

GPUs are not rated on the MHZ or the GHz. ONLY IDENTICAL GPUs can be compared like that i.e if you get an AMD7850 GPU made by ASUS vs MSI branded versions, say the base model designed by AMD at 800mhz. MSI and ASUS modify this design, put their own coolers and casings on the GPU allowing them to overclock the cards to perhaps 850mhz or 900mhz or whatever depending on their engineering ability.

 

Instead GPUs are rated on their FLOPS, in essence how many calculations they can carry out.

 

For this they use compute units.

 

PS4 GPU has 18 Compute Units provides 1.84 teraFLOPS of power.

 

XBOX One GPU has only 12 Compute units therefore provides 1.2 teraFLOPS of power.

 

After the overclock XBOX ONE is now 1.33 teraFLOPS. NOW 10% of this is reserved at all times by the kinect features in the OS whether you have it connected or not. so in reality it's 1.33-0.13 = 1.2 TFLOPS on the xbox one.

 

so 1.8tf-1.2tf=0.6tf

 

PS4 GPU is 0.6 Teraflops more POWERFUL than the GPU in XBOX ONE. That is 0.6/1.2 = 50%.

Message 65 of 66 (126 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Splicer
Registered: 10/04/2013
Offline
62 posts
 

Re: An Objective Comparison between Xbox One and PS4

Oct 27, 2013

PlayBox_One4 wrote:
Not a lie (Reduces difference from 30% to roughly 20% if the game uses XB1's CPU), although marginal was perhaps the wrong word. However, what's interesting about the XOne's CPU is graphics can be calculated on it.

20% is significant in statistics

Message 66 of 66 (120 Views)
Reply
0 Likes