I agree. I've never played Final Fantasy, but I want Cloud only because he's important to playstation. But it seems like all these 'experts' of Playstation games just played popular games and want to put them in. Fat Princess is a great choice. Oh wait, I dont have that game, now it's automatically a terrible choice.
Unorthadox is awesome. If this game had only the serious, gritty characters, I wouldn't have looked at it at 'all'. With the PS2 Mascot Trio and the inclusion of Fat Princess, Parappa, Spike, and Sir MANiel, I warmed up to it.
Heck I was the guy who said "How can there be All-Stars if the PS3 has no games".