I don't like to bet, but I put my money on Cole. I don't know if this got something to do with PSABR, but if it does, I hope it's not Lighting from FF XIII. I know I'm gonna recieve hates worldwide, but I'm not an RPG fan in general and certanly not a FF fan in particular. I can play some RPGs if they got some action/adventure/platafroms elements mixed in, but the classic RPG style bores me. BUT! I know FF it's an amazingly important franchise to Playstation, and I know FF VII in particular it's an important part in Playstation History. That's why, while don't liking that much the games (And the annoying fanboys), I believe Cloud deserves to be in, and not Lighting. I mean, I don't want to start a war here, but I didn't felt like FF XIII was an amazingly popular or a multiseller game... Hell, many people hated it. That didn't happened with VII. But I could be wrong, I don't know... As long as they don't put Tidus, I'm fine (I tried to play X a while ago... I still don't know how I gave the game so many hours without giving up).
But yeah.... If it's for me, the shadow that appears is Cole.
Kind-of Anticipating: God of War: Ascension, Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance, Aliens: Colonial Marines