No, the people who say this are **bleep** Nintendo fanboys.
Any true gamer won't use that as the sole reason to not play a game. As a gamer, if a game is fun for YOU to play it, you play it. It is as simple as that.
To be honest, EVEN if this game is a ripoff of SSBB (which it's not) I would STILL buy and play it. because, I do NOT have a Nintendo, I don't want to buy one because Nintendo have horrible region lock crap, therefore I want one for PS and this happens to be the closest one.
Playstation God of War Stars Battle Bore y'all !!!
Honestly, everything rips off something else in some way, and it's rare to see entirely original ideas. Not just in games, but in all media.
SSB and PS All-Stars are in the same genre and have massive similarities, and I honestly doubt this game would exist without Smash Bros, but to look at it and go "it's just a copy!", and dismiss it is rather sad.
But then on the flipside, I also disagree with people who don't feel the games should be compared, but I believe they should be, since they are similar enough to do so. Hell, the reason I'm excited for this game is because I've wanted a PS equivalent to Smash since the original on the N64, so the two being similar in that respect is actually a selling point for me, not something that puts me off.
i'd reply with "Oh, smash brothers is HD?" Of course I'm just a jerk and like annoying people lol
You know that is not HD which makes a game looking good, right?
In fact, Brawl is more beautiful to the eye even if it doesn't go over 480p (there is a component for the Wii but I don't like it nor need it).
I'm not expecting people here to realize that since you don't have any taste and you judge anything with numbers and words you can't even understand, but it's true.