I have to say, I certainly wouldn't mind having Croc in PS All Stars. It was published by Fox Interactive originally, which is now defunct, so it might be hard to establish the rights to use him. He'd definitely make a great addition though I think, the Croc games were part of what defined the original Playstation for me!
If you want dumb characters in this game you might as well keep asking for Crash and Spyro
IzoGray, how old are you? Croc was a pretty popular PS1 character...Definitly not that obscure or random...I've seen so many characters suggested on here with much less chance of getting in and are much less popular, (Jane Tate anyone?)
Croc is in the same boat as Tomba, 2nd tier PS1 icons. Still popular, just not as popular as Crash or Spyro obviously.
I loved croc back in the day and he was hugely popular. I'd say he was bigger than sir dan for example. But the thing is, people still remember sir dan while croc's now drifted into obscurity. I think he'd be awesome but he's not popular enough anymore. This game shouldn't be "lets put in as many PS1 characters we can think of" or "lets put in MY favourite characters and **bleep** everyone else" No offense obviously but I think the critera for getting into this game is that the character needs to have a strong relationship with sony (not necisarily 1st party) and that the character needs to be popular enough. Including obscure characters limits the amount of enjoyment the average person will get out of the game to a degree. The series isn't coming back from the dead any time soon so the franchise won't benefit. A large portion of the audience won't have been around when he was a big ame so they won't benefit. & crocs not gunna bring in sales so superbot & sony won't benefit. It just seems like if croc was included very few people would win. So to sum up He's in my ideal roster but for practicality reasons it's just not gunna happen.