Reply
Keyblade Wielder
Registered: 04/20/2005
Offline
10305 posts
 

Re: Who is telling the truth?

Mar 16, 2007


AdioX45 wrote:
So far 1 person has got it, but it was obviously a guess. Does anyone care to explain their answers?


Dude you can assure us there is a right answer because whoever made this up says its the right answer, but if you think about, we can never know. Based on what they are saying.. A says B is lying, so lets say B said A did it. or A could say B is lying when B said C did it. We just dont know..
Message 11 of 21 (0 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Fender Bender
Registered: 07/09/2005
Offline
3851 posts
 

Re: Who is telling the truth?

Mar 16, 2007
Thats like saying

The below statement is false
The above statement is true.


Message 12 of 21 (0 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Keyblade Wielder
Registered: 04/20/2005
Offline
10305 posts
 

Re: Who is telling the truth?

Mar 16, 2007


Jtboy wrote:
Thats like saying

The below statement is false
The above statement is true.



*head explodes*
Message 13 of 21 (0 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Fender Bender
Registered: 05/16/2006
Offline
3623 posts
 

Re: Who is telling the truth?

Mar 16, 2007
B is telling the truth. If C was telling the truth then B would be lying by saying C is lying but A would be telling the truth by saying B is lying so A and C would be telling the truth. Because of that B has to be telling the truth because since C cant be the truth teller and hes saying both A and B are lying which is false and A is saying B is lying which is false.

Message 14 of 21 (0 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Treasure Hunter
Registered: 12/24/2006
Offline
6062 posts
 

Re: Who is telling the truth?

Mar 16, 2007


Jtboy wrote:
Thats like saying

The below statement is false
The above statement is true.



So the top statement is true about the bottom statement that it is false???
 
Also to answer the thread creator's problem, I think it is B.
Message 15 of 21 (0 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Fender Bender
Registered: 12/24/2005
Offline
3418 posts
 

Re: Who is telling the truth?

Mar 16, 2007
You are 100% correct!

bhwinner99 wrote:
B is telling the truth. If C was telling the truth then B would be lying by saying C is lying but A would be telling the truth by saying B is lying so A and C would be telling the truth. Because of that B has to be telling the truth because since C cant be the truth teller and hes saying both A and B are lying which is false and A is saying B is lying which is false.



Message 16 of 21 (0 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Uncharted Territory
Registered: 07/12/2005
Offline
2123 posts
 

Re: Who is telling the truth?

Mar 17, 2007


Jtboy wrote:
Thats like saying

The below statement is false
The above statement is true.



I swear I was going to say that lol
Message 17 of 21 (0 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Uncharted Territory
Registered: 07/12/2005
Offline
2123 posts
 

Re: Who is telling the truth?

Mar 17, 2007


AdioX45 wrote:
You are 100% correct!

bhwinner99 wrote:
B is telling the truth. If C was telling the truth then B would be lying by saying C is lying but A would be telling the truth by saying B is lying so A and C would be telling the truth. Because of that B has to be telling the truth because since C cant be the truth teller and hes saying both A and B are lying which is false and A is saying B is lying which is false.


That confused me so badly


Message 18 of 21 (0 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Gaming Beast
Registered: 02/27/2007
Offline
2394 posts
 

Re: Who is telling the truth?

Mar 17, 2007
It's "A"
What is the point of having all three systems when I am going to be stuck playing one of them the whole time? I am getting a PS3 the day that Uncharted: Drakes Fortune comes out, the Xbox 360 just has too many flaws for so much money, and the Wii, I will NEVER get it. Oh, and if this has compared the systems, which I don't think it has, please remove it.

If I ever leave a smiley face as a post message, it is a link.
Message 19 of 21 (0 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Fender Bender
Registered: 05/16/2006
Offline
3623 posts
 

Re: Who is telling the truth?

Mar 17, 2007


Redrum wrote:


AdioX45 wrote:
You are 100% correct!

bhwinner99 wrote:
B is telling the truth. If C was telling the truth then B would be lying by saying C is lying but A would be telling the truth by saying B is lying so A and C would be telling the truth. Because of that B has to be telling the truth because since C cant be the truth teller and hes saying both A and B are lying which is false and A is saying B is lying which is false.


That confused me so badly




It confuses me also. I got it pretty quickly but it forever to explain and it still sounds a little weird.

Message 20 of 21 (0 Views)
Reply
0 Likes