Reply
Sep 09 2012
By: secretlyaturtle First Son 27 posts
Offline

PlayStation Trophies VS. Xbox Achievements

8 replies 466 views Edited Sep 9, 2012

I know I'm putting this on a PlayStation forum, but from an honest, Xbox AND PlayStation owner, what's better? Do you prefer the GamerScore or the PlayStation's rank system?

Message 1 of 9 (466 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Highlighted
Shinra Executive
Registered: 01/09/2010
Online
35847 posts
 

Re: PlayStation Trophies VS. Xbox Achievements

Sep 9, 2012

Having owned both both systems in the past but currently only a PS3 owner I think both systems have good & bad features.

Message 2 of 9 (455 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
MVP Support
Registered: 05/12/2009
Online
6814 posts
 

Re: PlayStation Trophies VS. Xbox Achievements

[ Edited ]
Sep 10, 2012

Trophies seem to be more satisfying for me. I like the leveling system and the way it's split into 4 categories; seems much more organized than the xbox achievement system.

Message 3 of 9 (443 Views)
PlayStation MVP
Registered: 03/15/2008
Offline
7332 posts
 

Re: PlayStation Trophies VS. Xbox Achievements

Sep 10, 2012

I don't understand how the Xbox achievements are worth earning: all one does is earn an achievement for points... You can't spend those points or determine which of those points were for hard achievements. If someone wanted, they could just earn easy achievements and pad their points.

 

Trophies are more enjoying to me, though. They're split into categories, and players can see which trophies you have, to find if you just earn the bronze trophies or go for the platinums; not to mention, you get a level that shows, in a way, how much of a dedicated, hardcore gamer you are Smiley Wink

soco signature

bhd clan site
mvp terms
forum rules
Message 4 of 9 (402 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Fender Bender
Registered: 03/09/2009
Offline
2559 posts
 

Re: PlayStation Trophies VS. Xbox Achievements

Sep 10, 2012

I also have both systems.  I know Xbox Achievements came first but I think trophies mean more to me.  Platinum trophies show how many games you fully completed.  Achievements are just points.  You can play countless games on Xbox and complete none of them and have a high "gamer score".  PS3, you can easily see if another person even completes the games on his profile.

 

But the level system in trophies makes no sense to me lol.

Juli photo juli6.gif
Message 5 of 9 (399 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
MVP Support
Registered: 08/04/2009
Online
5525 posts
 

Re: PlayStation Trophies VS. Xbox Achievements

Sep 10, 2012

I think trophies have the slight edge.  As Emerald_Swords said, they feel more organized, with specific values available for any game.  The platinum trophies give you an incentive to collect all trophies for a game.  There's not a huge difference between the two, but I think they are both better than Steam achievements, in which there is no total score and you can only compare on a game-specific basis.

Message 6 of 9 (393 Views)
Uncharted Territory
Registered: 05/15/2009
Offline
1368 posts
 

Re: PlayStation Trophies VS. Xbox Achievements

Sep 12, 2012
Nothing like the ding of a platinum'd game.
 photo EZRASIG_zpsf85694e2.jpg
Message 7 of 9 (354 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Fender Bender
Registered: 03/14/2008
Offline
3095 posts
 

Re: PlayStation Trophies VS. Xbox Achievements

Sep 12, 2012

Definitly trophies, just getting a platinum for a game you really have fun in is worth it, or sometimes you get the plantinum for a horrible game just to get your money's worth. I do like the feature to delete achievments, I wish I could delete some trophies.



"I'm not a failure because I didn't win, I'm a failure because I didn't try." - Kev

Message 8 of 9 (350 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Uncharted Territory
Registered: 04/22/2012
Offline
1532 posts
 

Re: PlayStation Trophies VS. Xbox Achievements

Sep 12, 2012

Both have their pros and cons.

 

I like the Trophies more because it give me the feeling of accomplishing something. While Xbox Achievement are just boring point, the PS Trophies are actually more sasify to earn, I wouldn't mind getting 2000 kills on COD on both system, but there is a different between a gold trophies and 50 points.

 

Second like everyone said, it's organized

 

But for one, I would actually prefer Xbox Achievements. As you earn point and rank up, you are actually rewarded with avatar, bonus, some game offer DLC for free if you manage to get all of the Achievement, some game give other game bonus via achievement like Ninja Gaiden 2 and Halo 3, by getting some achievment on NG2, you get an armor and sword on Halo 3. Kinda like how Steam reward player by getting achievement.

 

I for one suggest that Sony should use this method. You will earn trophies and bonus at the same time, make you feel better about yourself and keep you on the game longer eventhough it suck. I admit Marvel VS Capcom 3 suck hard to get trophies/achievement. But the bonus Avatar Iron Man helmet, Captain America Shield for my Xbox Home Avatar on the Xbox version keep me on the game Smiley Happy

I love Adam Levine
"One more ******* Love song and I well be sick......"
Message 9 of 9 (344 Views)
Reply
0 Likes