Reply
First Son
Registered: 11/08/2009
Offline
23 posts
 

Re: Plasma or LCD for gaming?

Jan 12, 2011

i really appreciate everyone's input. believe it or not it has been helpful. i am unable to get a DLP because i want to mount the TV. i would really like an LCD but the 50' price of a plasma is really looking good to me. its a samsung, so i am pretty sure its reliable. other than panasonic plasmas what other TV's are reliable? are Vizio's even worth looking at?

Message 31 of 80 (652 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Treasure Hunter
Registered: 07/29/2008
Offline
5263 posts
 

Re: Plasma or LCD for gaming?

Jan 13, 2011

raul777him wrote:

alex_the_awesome wrote:

Don't know why everybody keeps saying to avoid plasma's because of burn in. I have a fairly new plasma and I have tried burning an image onto it. I kept a racing game's HUD (MPH, Lap, Position, Map) paused on the display for a day straight and there was nothing.

Why would you TRY to burn in an image to a new plasma tv?

Doesn't make sense.

Bcause I can.

And because I purposefully tried to burn in an image and nothing happened just goes to show how much the technology has improved.

Message 32 of 80 (652 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Hekseville Citizen
Registered: 01/18/2009
Offline
330 posts
 

Re: Plasma or LCD for gaming?

Jan 13, 2011

My preference order:

  1. Plasma (for 600 Hz, not worried about burn in, maybe worried about heat/power consumption)
  2. LED (at least  240 Hz (Sony's Motionflow PRO 240 Hz is actually 480 Hz, because there is a frame of black in between each frame to "...reset your eyes, like after blinking, your view is clearer," says Sony rep at American)

Between a Panasonic Viera TC-P50VT25 (1080p 3D 50" Plasma) and a Sony BRAVIA KDL-46NX810 (1080p 3D 46" LED)(bought this one) I didn't notice a difference.

All I know about Vizio is it's America's #1 LCD HDTV Company.

BF3 Stats
Message 33 of 80 (652 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Umbrella Scientist
Registered: 12/08/2008
Offline
12347 posts
 

Re: Plasma or LCD for gaming?

Jan 17, 2011

bmoose8 wrote:

i really appreciate everyone's input. believe it or not it has been helpful. i am unable to get a DLP because i want to mount the TV.


Actually DLP's have been wall mountable since mine came out in 2007. 

They actually weigh much less then flat screen tvs of the same size.

My 2007 61" DLP weighs 68 pounds, a 61" plasma from the same year would easily weigh twice that.

Now you can get 82" DLP's that weigh about 100 pounds and are only a foot or so thick, but are still wall mountable.

If I was you I would either get a 50" 3D plasma from Samsung for around $500-$600.  This is if you on a budget and that will last you a while until truely great 3D tvs come around in the technologies you prefer.

Or a 82" Mitsubishi Lazer DLP this is if price isnt an issue and you want the absolute best tv on the market for gaming and 3D.

The color, speed, huge screen size and general picture quality cannot be beat.

IMHO LED/LCD tvs are a bunch of marketing hoopla.  The only advantage is if you get a RGB LED backlighting, the ones with white LEDs offer absolutely no advantage besides power savings.  Once 480hz or 600hz LCD's come around it may be there.

And so you know adding black frames between each displayed frame does not double the frame rate.

If that is the case then every DLP is actually twice the frame rate listed as they use white light protocol which displays a white frame between every actual frame.

Good luck.

Na13-31 wrote:
Finally, the structure of my question is that you would have to disprove every possible outcome to be correct and I would just have to have one that would likely be beneficial. That's statistically in my favor by quite a bit.


some_text
Message 34 of 80 (652 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Treasure Hunter
Registered: 07/20/2008
Offline
5436 posts
 

Re: Plasma or LCD for gaming?

Jan 20, 2011

sounds like a dlp fanboy has an LCD hate on!

320gb Slim
500gb Slim
SoftModded Wii with 640GB HDD
320gb XBox 360 S
LG 55" 120Hz LCD
LG 1000w 5.1
42" Panasonic Viera Plasma
4TB Media Server
320GB HD PVR

Playstation Plus Member

Gaming Since 1983
Message 35 of 80 (652 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Splicer
Registered: 11/02/2009
Offline
49 posts
 

Re: Plasma or LCD for gaming?

Sep 20, 2011

I was always taught that LCD is great for gaming and plasma should be used for movies.

Board games, video games and movie collector!

http://www.TheTradeBox.com - Win monthly prize giveaways!

What I'm Selling & Trading

My Videogames

My Movies
Message 36 of 80 (652 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Treasure Hunter
Registered: 07/21/2010
Offline
8267 posts
 

Re: Plasma or LCD for gaming?

Sep 20, 2011

No to Plasma

yes to LCD...

Though I want a LED

Message 37 of 80 (652 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Wastelander
Registered: 12/21/2004
Offline
837 posts
 

Re: Plasma or LCD for gaming?

Sep 20, 2011

I agree. I have had the Samsung C6500 for 11 months and game frequently. The most i had was mild image retention.

The anti-burn tools make it hard to get Burn in. i.e. pixel orbiting or shifting, Scrolling white washes your screen of retention.

If you leave a static image on any tv too long it will burn in. Some people say Plasmas are 600hz but actualy its 600hz subfield-motion

wich is still a 60 hz signal. The difference is subfield-motion eliminates motion blurr smoother. I have an LCD, LED and a PDP and they

are all good.

Message 38 of 80 (652 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Hekseville Citizen
Registered: 06/22/2010
Offline
301 posts
 

Re: Plasma or LCD for gaming?

Sep 20, 2011

a sony bravia is the best option dude.(but u will need money)

Message 39 of 80 (652 Views)
Reply
0 Likes
Ghost of Sparta
Registered: 11/27/2003
Offline
17115 posts
 

Re: Plasma or LCD for gaming?

Sep 20, 2011

Plasmas are not horrible for gaming. Many people are frightened that they might burn a HUD or a stationary image into the screen from video games and recommend to stay away from plasmas. However, they are very nice for quick action games and have unnoticable ghosting. Though LCD/LED are just as good nowadays, just depends on your budget and if there is a suitable television for that price.

Photobucket
Message 40 of 80 (652 Views)
Reply
0 Likes