Hey there good plp of GTA V you know what freaks me out on GTA V is when I go on a boat far out in the ocean its freaky bacause a Big red dot can show up on ur screen sometimes when out in the ocean on a boat what could that red dot be well...its a shark and im so terrified of sharks like really terrified there was this 1 time I was swimming under water looking for the UFO underwater and a Big red dot poped up on my map I new straight away what it was I freaked out and swam fast to my boat it felt so real lol.... and UFOs can be seen sometimes around GTA V like one on the Mountain when its nightime and thunder weather it is freaky to see a UFO on the Mountain at nightime and on a thunder weater on GTA V guys have you ever had freaky moments like me on GTA V? if so let me know Id love to hear it.
Red Dead Redemption isent that scarey it only scared me when I played the DLC of it Undead Nightmer...it really made me jump at times.
I'm assuming you didn't even play the side-mission where you have to deliver flowers to some stranger? The after-math was..... messed-up in a creepy and good way. And GTA5 wasn't even that scary :/