Haha chat topic...I'ma respond to Original post.
I do NOT like this idea! While I played the holy heck out of the first 3 GoW games, I would have platinumed 1 and 2 had I DONE IT ON PS3...but I played those on PS2 and although I DL'd the HD versions, it'd take a concerted effort and WAY too much time toplay through them again jjust to trophy hunt.
Also a friend of mine ruined my GoW3 disc at 83% trophy count so I never got to plat that one
DOwn with this idea! ...but I like the thought behind it...everything but the part where it screws me.