Would you be willing to answer a few brief questions about PlayStation Forums?
After killing the Spear holder twice the message still flashes but the spear doesn't drop.
I dunno... I had it drop like 4 times in one match for me. People who had it kept getting killed, and the oh-so-generous gods would just send down another, pronto.
IDK. It dropped multiple times. Like it was said: Peeps who had it kept getting killed